Go Back   CDN Business Directory > Main Category > Microsoft Money

 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 07-17-2003, 01:41 AM
Dick Watson
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Re: Asset allocation in MS Money (2004???)

$17 after rebate at Sam's Club? Have you looked at what Morningstar charges
lately?

"Paul S" <p_m_samson[at]hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:0b8501c34bec$e7b0baf0$a001280a[at]phx.gbl...
- quote -

> Come on,
> MS, with what we pay for this s/w, it should do better.


 
Old 07-16-2003, 11:52 PM
Paul S
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Asset allocation in MS Money (2004???)

This is one of my long standing peeves - if Morningstar
can "x-ray" the portfolio and give an asset allocation
for each fund, then MS could either develop a competitive
tool or license it form Morningstar and allow it to do
both individual funds and porfolio aggregate analysis.
To have to manually review each fund (which may change
its style over time) and to plug in some sort of
allocation into Excel seems hopelessly 1995. Come on,
MS, with what we pay for this s/w, it should do better.

- quote -

> -----Original Message-----
> The equity portion (all are mutual funds) of my
investment
> portfolio is as follows (asset class listed in quotes):
> 1. Vanguard S&P 500 Index Fund ("US Large Cap Blend
> Index"): 20%
> 2. Dodge and Cox Stock Fund ("US Large Cap Value Fund"):
> 20%
> 3. Vanguard REIT Index ("REIT Index"): 10%
> 4. Vanguard Small Cap Value Index Fund("US Small Cap
Value
> Index"): 15%
> 5. Bridgeway Ultra Small Cap Index Fund ("US Micro Cap
> Index"): 15%
> 6. Vanguard Int'l Emerging Markets Index Fund ("Int'l
> Emerging Market Index"): 10%
> 7. Vanguard European Markets Index Fund ("Europe Market
> Index"): 10%
> I bought MS Money 2003 Deluxe for the sole purpose to
> simplify my investment portfolio (and also as a
> checkbook). I bought Money to set up my target
allocation
> of assets (above) so when I re-balance every year, it
will
> be easy to see what has grown and what needs to be sold
to
> get it back to my "ideal" (or target) asset allocation.
> My ideal allocation is above. I was SORELY disappointed
> to have a program packed with so many features that does
> NOT have the ability to accurately track an asset
> allocation seen above. The only way MS Money '03 Deluxe
> broke it down was "Large, Mid, and Small US equity,
> International Equity, and Bonds." Why O Why doesn't MS
> Money let the user (me) write in the names of the asset
> categories!! That way I can customize my investment
> assets to say "Int'l Emerging Markets Index Fund"
> or "Micro cap Index Fund." MS Money 2003 Deluxe is very
> crude in how it breaks up major asset classes. There
are
> so many more asset classes than the broad asset
> classes: "Large, Mid and Small US equity, International
> Equity."
> Does anyone know if Money 2004 Premium will have this
> BASIC feature? The only other way I can see to break it
> up is to use MS Excel. That means I'd have to write a
> program to get my investment transactions from MS Money
to
> MS Excel. Once in Excel, I can then create graphs to
see
> which asset class has grown too much (also show
> percentages of each vs. total) and therefore I need to
> rebalance. Man, I hope Money 2004 has this very, very,
> fundamental aspect to investing. I simply can't
implement
> the sound principles of "Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT)"
> without this breakdown of asset classes. For crying out
> loud, MS Money should at least have "REITs" and other
> asset classes that comprise most diversified investors'
> portfolios.
> If MS Money 2004 doesn't have these features, I'm stuck
> writing a crude Excel sheet to manage my investment
> portfolio.
> Any replies would be helpful.
> Thanks all
> .
  #-1  
Old 07-16-2003, 07:22 PM
turbo_dog
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Asset allocation in MS Money (2004???)

The equity portion (all are mutual funds) of my investment
portfolio is as follows (asset class listed in quotes):

1. Vanguard S&P 500 Index Fund ("US Large Cap Blend
Index"): 20%
2. Dodge and Cox Stock Fund ("US Large Cap Value Fund"):
20%
3. Vanguard REIT Index ("REIT Index"): 10%
4. Vanguard Small Cap Value Index Fund("US Small Cap Value
Index"): 15%
5. Bridgeway Ultra Small Cap Index Fund ("US Micro Cap
Index"): 15%
6. Vanguard Int'l Emerging Markets Index Fund ("Int'l
Emerging Market Index"): 10%
7. Vanguard European Markets Index Fund ("Europe Market
Index"): 10%

I bought MS Money 2003 Deluxe for the sole purpose to
simplify my investment portfolio (and also as a
checkbook). I bought Money to set up my target allocation
of assets (above) so when I re-balance every year, it will
be easy to see what has grown and what needs to be sold to
get it back to my "ideal" (or target) asset allocation.
My ideal allocation is above. I was SORELY disappointed
to have a program packed with so many features that does
NOT have the ability to accurately track an asset
allocation seen above. The only way MS Money '03 Deluxe
broke it down was "Large, Mid, and Small US equity,
International Equity, and Bonds." Why O Why doesn't MS
Money let the user (me) write in the names of the asset
categories!! That way I can customize my investment
assets to say "Int'l Emerging Markets Index Fund"
or "Micro cap Index Fund." MS Money 2003 Deluxe is very
crude in how it breaks up major asset classes. There are
so many more asset classes than the broad asset
classes: "Large, Mid and Small US equity, International
Equity."

Does anyone know if Money 2004 Premium will have this
BASIC feature? The only other way I can see to break it
up is to use MS Excel. That means I'd have to write a
program to get my investment transactions from MS Money to
MS Excel. Once in Excel, I can then create graphs to see
which asset class has grown too much (also show
percentages of each vs. total) and therefore I need to
rebalance. Man, I hope Money 2004 has this very, very,
fundamental aspect to investing. I simply can't implement
the sound principles of "Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT)"
without this breakdown of asset classes. For crying out
loud, MS Money should at least have "REITs" and other
asset classes that comprise most diversified investors'
portfolios.

If MS Money 2004 doesn't have these features, I'm stuck
writing a crude Excel sheet to manage my investment
portfolio.

Any replies would be helpful.

Thanks all
 

Tags
2004, allocation, asset, money


Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off

All times are GMT. The time now is 11:22 AM.