|
#4
| |||
| |||
| "nomail1983[at]hotmail.com" <nomail1983[at]hotmail.com> writes: - quote - > On Apr 9, 12:53 pm, "W. Wells" <o...[at]nc.rr.com> wrote:
Not in the stocks and funds world. At its simplest, yield is> > Which is better for income: A CD paying 5% or a fund yielding 4.83% > > and growing [at] an average of 5% per year? > For my edification, please explain those terms with respect to the > fund. I thought "yield" and "growth" were almost synonyms, except dividends divided by price. Growth is increase in price. And total return is yield plus growth. (The math's actually a bit more complicated than that, but that states the fundamental concepts well). -- Rich Carreiro rlcarr[at]animato.arlington.ma.us |
|
#3
| |||
| |||
| On Apr 9, 12:53 pm, "W. Wells" <o...[at]nc.rr.com> wrote: - quote - > Which is better for income: A CD paying 5% or a fund yielding 4.83%
For my edification, please explain those terms with respect to the> and growing [at] an average of 5% per year? fund. I thought "yield" and "growth" were almost synonyms, except that in this context, 4.83% might be the 7-day yield, whereas 5% might be an historical average over some (how many?) months or years. In any case, I could not answer the question without knowing the volatility (std dev) of the fund growth rate, what the fund invests in, your tolerance for risk, and your time horizon. Also, is the CD rate fixed or variable? - quote - > Would I be better off putting my money
The correct answer depends on individual factors that you have> in the fund and drawing out 5% per year (my income) ? not even hinted at. Obviously if you depend on 5% per year income from these funds, the CD is not an option, no matter how the yields compare. Most CDs do not allow you to make withdrawals (without penalty) until maturity. (Exceptions are made for RMDs from Traditional IRAs.) But that does not necessarily make the fund your "best" option. |
|
#2
| |||
| |||
| The fund's a no brainer: Its principal keeps up with inflation (at least, as inflation is conventionally measured) while you still get around 5% income from it each year. |
|
#1
| |||
| |||
| On Apr 9, 10:53 pm, "W. Wells" <o...[at]nc.rr.com> wrote: - quote - > Which is better for income: A CD paying 5% or a fund yielding 4.83% and
Is the 4.83% yield of the fund sure, or just expected? Also, is the> growing [at] an average of 5% per year? Would I be better off putting my money > in the fund and drawing out 5% per year (my income) ? The fund expense > ration is .44%. > Am I missing something here are is this a no brainer to use the fund? 4.83%yield net of expenses, or gross? If 4.83% is the net yield and as safe as the 5% yield of the CD (i.e., you apply the same discount rate to the two streams of income), then the net present value of the fund is higher than the net present value of the CD if you plan to hold both investments for 3 years or more. |
| | |||
| |||
| On Apr 9, 1:53 pm, "W. Wells" <o...[at]nc.rr.com> wrote: - quote - > Which is better for income: A CD paying 5% or a fund yielding 4.83% and > growing [at] an average of 5% per year? Would I be better off putting my money > in the fund and drawing out 5% per year (my income) ? The fund expense > ration is .44%. > Am I missing something here are is this a no brainer to use the fund? You have a fund that's yielding 4.83% a year and growing at an average of 5% a year on top of that? What's the name of this fund? |
|
#-1
| |||
| |||
| Which is better for income: A CD paying 5% or a fund yielding 4.83% and growing [at] an average of 5% per year? Would I be better off putting my money in the fund and drawing out 5% per year (my income) ? The fund expense ration is .44%. Am I missing something here are is this a no brainer to use the fund? |
| Tags |
| income, place |
Similar Threads | ||||
| Thread | Forum | Replies | Last Post | |
| What is the best place to have an IRA ?? l0200100@yahoo.com: What is the best place to have an IRA ?? I am looking for the place with the highest yielding cash sweep, so that I can park all my retirement... | Financial Planning | 1 | 08-23-2006 09:00 AM | |
| Good place for tax audio CDs? Schultz: I'm looking to get audio CD's containing discussions of federal income tax law. For example, individual tax, corporate tax, partnership tax, etc. ... | Taxes | 3 | 08-30-2005 05:16 AM | |
| Cheapest place to buy M2004? Aloke Prasad: Sorry to reprieve this thread, but now that the dust has settled, where is the best place to buy M2004 Deluxe? It's for $40 (after rebates) at... | Microsoft Money | 21 | 09-26-2003 02:01 AM | |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | |
| |