| | |||
| |||
| rick++ wrote: - quote - > I was noticing the similiarities of a Roth 401K to a VA.
The best part of the VA you missed is that all gains are then taxed at> Are these items accurate: > Both are funded with post-tax dollars; earnings are deferred. > Both have have 10% tax penalty if withdrawals before five years. > A Roth has no mandatory age withdrawal. A VA matures at some > future contract date which can be age 90 (or later?). > Roth contributions have an AGI limitation and ceiling amount. > A VA has no AGI limitation or ceiling amount. > A VA has an insurance wrapper overhead of at least 0.25%. > It may have early withdrawal penalties beyond the federal one, > but some dont. > A Roth can be inherited wihout paying immediate taxes. > The gains in a VA are taxes when inherited. > The insurance part of a VA can be structured for additional > benefits such guaranteeing principal, death benefit etc, > but that may increase the insurance amount. ordinary rates upon withdrawal. So even after the years of "only" .25% overhead, you get to support uncle sam on the back end. JOE |
|
#-1
| |||
| |||
| I was noticing the similiarities of a Roth 401K to a VA. Are these items accurate: Both are funded with post-tax dollars; earnings are deferred. Both have have 10% tax penalty if withdrawals before five years. A Roth has no mandatory age withdrawal. A VA matures at some future contract date which can be age 90 (or later?). Roth contributions have an AGI limitation and ceiling amount. A VA has no AGI limitation or ceiling amount. A VA has an insurance wrapper overhead of at least 0.25%. It may have early withdrawal penalties beyond the federal one, but some dont. A Roth can be inherited wihout paying immediate taxes. The gains in a VA are taxes when inherited. The insurance part of a VA can be structured for additional benefits such guaranteeing principal, death benefit etc, but that may increase the insurance amount. |
| Tags |
| 401k, annuity, roth, variable, versus |
Similar Threads | ||||
| Thread | Forum | Replies | Last Post | |
| Variable annuity in 401k, what to do? ScottF: I recently became eligible to join the 401k plan at work. I had a small amount in a rollover IRA (I think that's what it's called) awaiting plan... | Financial Planning | 5 | 09-18-2005 11:30 PM | |
| Variable annuity in 401k, what to do? ScottF: Here is the latest on my saga. Spoke with the plan administrator on Friday. He is an outside contractor, btw. The money is invested in a... | Financial Planning | 1 | 09-12-2005 10:20 PM | |
| Variable annuity in 401k, what to do? BMS: Not all variable annuities are the same. For small companies, a product called a Master Variable Annuity is used for the defined contribution plan.... | Financial Planning | 8 | 09-09-2005 11:36 PM | |
| Variable annuity in 401k chris-mead@softhome.net: Our company offers a Variable Annuity 401k through Citistreet Goldtrack Express and the more I look into it the more concerned I am as an... | Financial Planning | 3 | 06-17-2004 09:05 AM | |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | |
| |