|
#6
| |||
| |||
| allgyerj[at]hotmail.com wrote: - quote - > Ian, > I am curious why you would want to invest Roth money into a money > market? How old are you? > The reason for my curiosity is that a money market typically invests in > T-Bills and other short term debt securities. This makes the money > market highly liquid (you can get your money in and out of it quickly), > but the cost of this liquidity/lower risk is a lower rate of return. > A Roth is a retirement vehicle, which is designed to hold money for a > long time prior to distribuiton. > So, those two ideas are in conflict unless you are at or near 59 1/2 > years of age. > What are you hoping to accomplish through your investment in a money > market? I assume he's hoping to earn more than 1% interest on the cash that's sitting in the account waiting to be invested. (My Roth IRA is almost 5% in cash right now, and a better-managed account might be 20% or more in cash for weeks or months at a time) Bob |
|
#5
| |||
| |||
| Ian, I am curious why you would want to invest Roth money into a money market? How old are you? The reason for my curiosity is that a money market typically invests in T-Bills and other short term debt securities. This makes the money market highly liquid (you can get your money in and out of it quickly), but the cost of this liquidity/lower risk is a lower rate of return. A Roth is a retirement vehicle, which is designed to hold money for a long time prior to distribuiton. So, those two ideas are in conflict unless you are at or near 59 1/2 years of age. What are you hoping to accomplish through your investment in a money market? |
|
#4
| |||
| |||
| On Thu, 12 Jan 2006 15:56:58 -0600, Bucky <uw_badgers[at]email.com> wrote: - quote - > > Ian Pilcher wrote:
Actually you might need something like $2500 to open a Fidelity account> > > Unfortunately, they charge a low balance fee if you're under $5,000. > > > (I guess they only want people over 50 as their customers?) > If you're a low roller =) you can look into Fidelity instead. I believe > that their Roth IRA account has no minimum balance fees anymore. The > way that Fidelity accounts work is that they have a designated core > fund that non-invested money goes into. In the case of Roth IRA, the > core fund is Fidelity Cash Reserves money market (FDRXX). The 7-day > yield on that is 3.97%, compared to Vanguard prime MM 4.01%. You can > confirm with a Fidelity rep, but I'm pretty sure that the minimum > investment and small balance fees are not applicable when it is used as > a core fund. So you should be able to open a Fidelity Roth IRA with > $100 and get the 3.97% yield without fees. (unless you make automatic payments). But if you spend that on mutual funds or stocks there is no minimum balance for your core cash MM account. The cash in my IRA and Roth IRA has sometimes been less than $30 and they still pay interest on it with no fees. If you buy any stocks in a retirement account, make sure you use limit orders, especially if you do not have much cash left. Not sure what they do if a market order would end up higher than your available cash (maybe an automatic cancel). |
|
#3
| |||
| |||
| - quote - > Ian Pilcher wrote:
If you're a low roller =) you can look into Fidelity instead. I believe> > Unfortunately, they charge a low balance fee if you're under $5,000. > > (I guess they only want people over 50 as their customers?) that their Roth IRA account has no minimum balance fees anymore. The way that Fidelity accounts work is that they have a designated core fund that non-invested money goes into. In the case of Roth IRA, the core fund is Fidelity Cash Reserves money market (FDRXX). The 7-day yield on that is 3.97%, compared to Vanguard prime MM 4.01%. You can confirm with a Fidelity rep, but I'm pretty sure that the minimum investment and small balance fees are not applicable when it is used as a core fund. So you should be able to open a Fidelity Roth IRA with $100 and get the 3.97% yield without fees. Another consideration for Fidelity vs Vanguard is that Vanguard is primarily a mutual fund company. Vanguard is not very good for buying stocks or ETFs. You have to open a separate brokerage account at Vanguard to buy stocks, and the commissions are pretty expensive. You probably don't want to transfer Roth IRA accounts (it usually costs $50 or more), so you might want to think it through before opening one. |
|
#2
| |||
| |||
| Ian Pilcher wrote: - quote - > joe.spam.weinstein[at]gmail.com wrote: > > Vanguard will host your Roth IRA. They have > > low costs, and their prime money market fund > > does very well. They also have a very good > > tax-exempt moneymarket fund for your regular > > accounts if you're in a high bracket. > Unfortunately, they charge a low balance fee if you're under $5,000. > (I guess they only want people over 50 as their customers?) To avoid the fee, young'uns can open an account between Jan 1 and Apr 15, making simultaneous contributions for the current and previous tax years, thus opening the account with up to $8000. Bob |
|
#1
| |||
| |||
| joe.spam.weinstein[at]gmail.com wrote: - quote - > Vanguard will host your Roth IRA. They have
Unfortunately, they charge a low balance fee if you're under $5,000.> low costs, and their prime money market fund > does very well. They also have a very good > tax-exempt moneymarket fund for your regular > accounts if you're in a high bracket. (I guess they only want people over 50 as their customers?) -- ================================================== ====================== Ian Pilcher i.pilcher[at]comcast.net ================================================== ====================== |
|
#-1
| |||
| |||
| I am looking for a Roth IRA provider that offers a high yield (net of costs) money market fund. Any suggestions? Thanks! -- ================================================== ====================== Ian Pilcher i.pilcher[at]comcast.net ================================================== ====================== |
| Tags |
| high, ira, market, money, roth, yield |
Similar Threads | ||||
| Thread | Forum | Replies | Last Post | |
| Is high yield savings account good for short term investing? jen: i came across ingdirect.com they offer 3.30% APY. that seem to give better return than money market and short term bond funds. what are your... | Financial Planning | 7 | 09-21-2005 01:10 PM | |
| ETF And/Or Timer-friendly High Yield Bond Funds Percy Labrada: As a "knee-jerk" reaction to mutual fund scandals, many mutual fund companies are really clamping down on market timers. I trade exclusive high... | Financial Planning | 2 | 02-14-2004 10:08 PM | |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | |
| |