Go Back   CDN Business Directory > Main Category > Financial Planning

 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #5  
Old 09-07-2004, 03:40 PM
SD
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Re: 0% credit card for CD?

Paul Michael Brown wrote:

- quote -

> > I know it would be tricky -- a mistake, overlooked fee, or late
> > payment would be costly. Other than that, what's the catch?

> It's quite a bit of work for not very much money.
> I'll assume that it's possible to get a cash advance on the
> interest-charging credit card without a fee. (Although I think that's a
> stretch.) I'll also be generous and assume it's possible to find a 90-day
> CD paying 2.0 percent per year. (If anybody finds one of these, let me
> know.) On $10,000, that's $200 per year. For three months, that's $50. But
> that's pre-tax. Again, let's be generous and assume a combined marginal
> tax rate of 20 percent. So the after-tax return for all this work is $40.


Yes it is pointless for three months but not for 6 months or a year.
Also why would one need a CD when there is INGDirect savongs at 2.2%.
Also it isnt much effort at all! Personally I got a 0APR for a year and
kept spending on it till I reached the limit and I kept getting offers
for 0APr with no balance transfer fees and kept transferring/spending
more while making payments to my savings account instead of the cards.

- quote -

> As Tony Soprano would say, nuthin' for nuthin' but there are far easier
> ways to make $40. You could skip a couple of trips to Bennigans for
> dinner, you could put in a few hours of overtime, or you could watch TV at
> home instead of taking your family to a movie. I realize that "frugal
> living" posts are generally off topic here. But my point is that it seems
> like quite a bit of hassle for a very small return and you could do just
> as well in other ways.


I understand all this frugal living stuff - why not watch the movie at
home *AND* make the extra 40 (~ 9 movies from Blockbuster)!

  #4  
Old 09-07-2004, 03:40 PM
SD
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Re: 0% credit card for CD?

Rambo Sythia wrote:

- quote -

> Hi. I couldn't find this as a FAQ, but I'd be surprised if it's
> not. Anyway, I have a credit card with a high credit limit, like
> $15,000, and I just got a "0% 'til March 2005" offer from another
> card.
> I think it's illegal to buy stocks on 100% margin, but would it be
> illegal to do the following?
> * get $10,000 cash advance from the old card
> * transfer the balance to the new card with 0% interest
> * get 3-month CD, move it to savings account after 3 mo.
> * pay off new card before interest starts in March
> I know it would be tricky -- a mistake, overlooked fee, or late
> payment would be costly. Other than that, what's the catch?

Nothing. I've been doing this for over a year now. I put my money in an
ING Savings account at 2.2% and use the 0 APR cards. Most of them also
have no balance transfer fees. If they do, ask them to waive the fees
and they probably will do that. When the 0APR gets over, I pay off the
cards.

  #3  
Old 09-07-2004, 01:04 AM
Cal Lester
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Re: 0% credit card for CD?


- quote -

> As Tony Soprano would say, nuthin' for nuthin' but there are far easier
> ways to make $40. You could skip a couple of trips to Bennigans for
> dinner, you could put in a few hours of overtime, or you could watch TV at
> home instead of taking your family to a movie. I realize that "frugal
> living" posts are generally off topic here. But my point is that it seems
> like quite a bit of hassle for a very small return and you could do just
> as well in other ways.


No one ever "splained it dat way befo"

Cal


  #2  
Old 09-06-2004, 10:49 PM
Rambo Sythia
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Re: 0% credit card for CD?

pmb[at]his.com (Paul Michael Brown) writes:

- quote -

> > I know it would be tricky -- a mistake, overlooked fee, or late
> > payment would be costly. Other than that, what's the catch?

> It's quite a bit of work for not very much money.
> I'll assume that it's possible to get a cash advance on the
> interest-charging credit card without a fee. (Although I think that's a
> stretch.) I'll also be generous and assume it's possible to find a 90-day
> CD paying 2.0 percent per year. (If anybody finds one of these, let me
> know.) On $10,000, that's $200 per year. For three months, that's $50. But
> that's pre-tax. Again, let's be generous and assume a combined marginal
> tax rate of 20 percent. So the after-tax return for all this work is $40.
> As Tony Soprano would say, nuthin' for nuthin' but there are far easier
> ways to make $40. You could skip a couple of trips to Bennigans for
> dinner, you could put in a few hours of overtime, or you could watch TV at
> home instead of taking your family to a movie. I realize that "frugal
> living" posts are generally off topic here. But my point is that it seems
> like quite a bit of hassle for a very small return and you could do just
> as well in other ways.


Thanks, John A. Weeks III and Paul Michael Brown. When you put it
that way, it's not surprising that it's legal.

--
R4S


======================================= MODERATOR'S COMMENT:
Please trim the post to which you respond.

  #1  
Old 09-06-2004, 04:00 PM
Paul Michael Brown
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Re: 0% credit card for CD?

- quote -

> I know it would be tricky -- a mistake, overlooked fee, or late
> payment would be costly. Other than that, what's the catch?


It's quite a bit of work for not very much money.

I'll assume that it's possible to get a cash advance on the
interest-charging credit card without a fee. (Although I think that's a
stretch.) I'll also be generous and assume it's possible to find a 90-day
CD paying 2.0 percent per year. (If anybody finds one of these, let me
know.) On $10,000, that's $200 per year. For three months, that's $50. But
that's pre-tax. Again, let's be generous and assume a combined marginal
tax rate of 20 percent. So the after-tax return for all this work is $40.

As Tony Soprano would say, nuthin' for nuthin' but there are far easier
ways to make $40. You could skip a couple of trips to Bennigans for
dinner, you could put in a few hours of overtime, or you could watch TV at
home instead of taking your family to a movie. I realize that "frugal
living" posts are generally off topic here. But my point is that it seems
like quite a bit of hassle for a very small return and you could do just
as well in other ways.

 
Old 09-06-2004, 04:00 PM
John A. Weeks III
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Re: 0% credit card for CD?

In article <87vfesm9g5.fsf[at]noserose.net> , Rambo Sythia
<rambo4sythia[at]safe-mail.net> wrote:

- quote -

> Hi. I couldn't find this as a FAQ, but I'd be surprised if it's
> not. Anyway, I have a credit card with a high credit limit, like
> $15,000, and I just got a "0% 'til March 2005" offer from another
> card.
> I think it's illegal to buy stocks on 100% margin, but would it be
> illegal to do the following?
> * get $10,000 cash advance from the old card
> * transfer the balance to the new card with 0% interest
> * get 3-month CD, move it to savings account after 3 mo.
> * pay off new card before interest starts in March
> I know it would be tricky -- a mistake, overlooked fee, or late
> payment would be costly. Other than that, what's the catch?


Most of the 0% deals that I know of still have a fee for taking
the money out. That fee is from 1% to 3%, often with some kind
of a cap. Lets assume in your case that it is $50.

CD's are not paying all that much. Lets say you get one for
4%. 10,000 x 4% = $400, divide by 4 to get the 3 month return,
which is $100.

Your $100 profit less $50 fee nets you a cool profit of $50.
Hardly seems worth the effort of the bookeeping that is required,
and the risk if something goes bad is very high. For example,
if one of your minimum payments gets lost in the mail, and you
get a late fee by accident, they may jack up your 0% to 21.99%.
In this case, you get a $29 late fee, which blows most of your
profit, and you are stuck with $183 a month in interest payments
until you can find $10K to pay off the credit card (remember,
your $10K that you borrowed is locked up in the CD, and you
cannot get to it for 90 days).

If you have other high interest rate cards that you can pay
off doing this, then perhaps it would be worth it. But not
for $50 as your maximum upside.

-john-

--
================================================== ==================
John A. Weeks III 952-432-2708 john[at]johnweeks.com
Newave Communications http://www.johnweeks.com
================================================== ==================

  #-1  
Old 09-06-2004, 10:02 AM
Rambo Sythia
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default 0% credit card for CD?

Hi. I couldn't find this as a FAQ, but I'd be surprised if it's
not. Anyway, I have a credit card with a high credit limit, like
$15,000, and I just got a "0% 'til March 2005" offer from another
card.

I think it's illegal to buy stocks on 100% margin, but would it be
illegal to do the following?

* get $10,000 cash advance from the old card

* transfer the balance to the new card with 0% interest

* get 3-month CD, move it to savings account after 3 mo.

* pay off new card before interest starts in March

I know it would be tricky -- a mistake, overlooked fee, or late
payment would be costly. Other than that, what's the catch?

--
R4S

 

Tags
card, credit
Similar Threads
Thread Forum Replies Last Post
Money 2007 and FIA Card Services Credit Card
Don Awalt: I am starting to use my first credit card where Money does not get transactions from a bank directly. When I set up the FIA Card Services credit...
Microsoft Money 2 02-04-2007 08:22 PM
Money is limited to one credit card account per credit card company.
barry milliken: My wife and I have seperate american express card accounts (not 2 cards on the same account). On the web we have separate login ids and passwords...
Microsoft Money 3 04-13-2006 01:06 PM
Charge/credit backwards on credit card
cbspamtrap@gmail.com: Hi, I set up a new credit card account in Money 2006 and used online services to update the transactions. It downloaded without reporting...
Microsoft Money 3 03-06-2006 01:19 AM
Credit card transactions downloading as Credit
Venkat: In MS Money 2006 my credit card transactions download as credit instead of charge. Please don't tell me this is how it should be or that it is by...
Microsoft Money 2 10-08-2005 08:58 PM



Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are Off
Pingbacks are Off
Refbacks are Off

All times are GMT. The time now is 11:08 AM.